Home » RESEARCH/ARTICLES/BlOG » WHY EXCLUDE JEFFERSON?

WAYS TO HELP OUT

We are a 501c3 non profit organization designed to spread conservative values on campus. Your contributions are tax deductible. To donate by mail send contributions to Students For A Better Future.Com P.O. Box 436 Mount Tabor, NJ 07878-0436

Subscribe

WHY EXCLUDE JEFFERSON?

 

By

 

Dr Joe Arminio
Principal Instructor
Homeschool Curriculum Improved
http://www.home-school-curriculum-improved.com

 

August 8, 2013

 

 

 

Russell Kirk’s famous book, The Conservative Mind, is getting a lot of press lately, on account of this being the sixtieth anniversary of its publication. For those wanting to get to the heart of his message quickly, there is the refreshing, even if equally old, distillation, that is, his article entitled “The Essence Of Conservatism.” This important article contains a bold enumeration of ten principles that, he believes, ought to inform the conservative movement.  It also casts the spotlight upon the origins of American Conservatism, especially the thinking of Alexander Hamilton, John Adams and the Federalists. But shouldn’t Jefferson and the top Republicans of his day also be included in the pantheon of American Conservatism?

 

In what way did Jefferson—the “pen of the [American] revolution”—our third president, and other glittering credentials–fail to live up to any of Kirk’s ten principles? The only thing I can think of is, some shall say Jefferson failed in regard to the tenth principle, which counsels against risky “innovation,” and which reads at length, thus: “… moral and political innovation can be destructive as well as beneficial; and if innovation is undertaken in a spirit of presumption and exuberance, probably it will be disastrous.”  Specifically, Jefferson disappoints some because they say he preferred unstable, risk-taking France to “conservative” Great Britain.

 

Does adherence to Kirk’s aforementioned tenth principle require Jefferson to prefer Great Britain at all times? It does not. It is true that, during the period in question, the British sidestepped any violent political “innovation.” On the other hand, France had been our principal Revolutionary War ally. Why, then, take the Jeffersonians to task for tilting toward France? So where lies the rub? Is it Jefferson’s continued enthusiasm for France, on into the French Revolution?  Yet, his enthusiasm waxed at the onset but waned when their experiment became synonymous with chaos and the guillotine.

 

If there is no failure in regard to principle number ten, why should any conservative still dislike Jefferson? Could the unease some feel toward him actually be the byproduct of excessive hero worship of the Federalists? The Federalists, it is true, were the prime authors of the revered Constitution, including such remarkable things as its checks-and-balances. Jefferson applauded those sorts of things. Yet he also pointed out other things—such as, in his letter to Lafayette of 1792–, that “stock jobbers” and “king jobbers” were increasingly entering the government. Such veiled rebuke (and, elsewhere, open rebuke) of the party that authored the core of the supreme law of the land have drawn the ire of many—then and now.

 

What if the truth of our founding is complex? What if the Federalists were not always heroes? You have, for instance, the absence of a Bill Of Rights when they emerged from secret session in Philadelphia in 1787. You have their insistence upon the muzzling Alien and Seditions Acts of 1798. Nor was Jefferson without blemish.

 

Would that more conservatives today wrestle with the full historical record, however inconvenient or challenging it may be in places. As a result, the critics of the man of Monticello just might alter their opinion. And, even better informed, they could make even better use of such insights as Kirk’s ten principles of Conservatism.

 

 

 

Editor’s Note.

 

For a further discussion of Conservatism, see …
http://www.home-school-curriculum-improved.com/conservatism.html.

Weekly Podcasts

Channel 21 LANTV New Jersey Current Programming


Upcoming Podcast

  • Totalitarian Thought
    Totalitarian Thought
    Totalitarianism is a term used by some political scientists to describe a political system in which the state holds total authority over the society and seeks to control all aspects of public and private life wherever possible. Read More Here:   
  • Immigration reform
    Immigration reform
    Under a Trump Presidency, how will our Immigration System be revamped. Learn More:
  • What's Life Like Under A Trump Presidency?
    What's Life Like Under A Trump Presidency?
    Will you have a job? Will Obamacare be repealed? Learn more:

RSS Seton Hall Sports

  • AP Top 25 college basketball poll: New high for Seton Hall
    Seton Hall is riding a four-game winning streak, which includes victories over Louisville and Texas Tech. The Pirates (8-1) had been ranked No. 19 in last week's poll. Watch video It's onward and upward for the Seton Hall men's basketball team, which reached new heights in the AP Top 25 poll, checking in at No. 15 […]
  • 7 takeaways from Seton Hall's blowout win over VCU
    Everything we learned from the action as Seton Hall downed VCU at Prudential Center.
  • Seton Hall rides defense, balanced scoring past VCU, 90-67 | Rapid reaction
    Seton Hall secured another impressive victory, this time besting VCU at Prudential Center. Seton Hall continued its challenging out-of-conference schedule in the run-up to Big East play on Saturday. But VCU proved to be not much of a challenge for the Pirates. Riding a standout defensive performance and a balanced scoring outburst, No. 19 Seton Hall […]
  • Seton Hall honoring 9/11 victims with Never Forget Classic warm-up shirts
    Seton Hall will pay homage to those from its community that passed away on September 11. Watch video As No. 19 Seton Hall warms up for the Never Forget Tribute Classic on Saturday, the Pirates will honor 14 members of the school's community who were killed in the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The Pirates will […]
  • Desi Rodriguez's game-winner sends Seton Hall past No. 17 Louisville
    Seton Hall topped Louisville on Sunday, with Desi Rodriguez providing the game-winning shot. Watch video Seton Hall had a chance for a second straight marquee victory on Sunday, and Desi Rodriguez made sure the Pirates didn't miss it. Rodriguez hit a running layup with eight seconds left to give Seton Hall a 79-77 victory over No. […]
  • Seton Hall falls out of AP Top 25 college basketball poll
    Seton Hall began the season at No. 23 in the AP Top 25 college basketball poll. But the Pirates lost on Thanksgiving to Rhode Island, before bouncing back the next night to beat Vanderbilt and improve to 6-1 this season. The Associated Press released its updated Top 25 men's college basketball poll on Monday. For […]
  • AP Top 25 college basketball poll: Seton Hall climbs higher
    Seton Hall has won its first four games of the season. It's the second time the Pirates have started the season 4-0 under head coach Kevin Willard. Another pair of wins has Seton Hall knocking on the door of the top 20. Last Wednesday, the Pirates beat Indiana, 84-68. Two days later, Seton Hall took care […]
  • 6 takeaways from Seton Hall's convincing victory over Indiana
    Seton Hall bested Indiana for its third victory of the season at Prudential Center.
Skip to toolbar